Chausson: Piece for cello & piano (1897)

patience... (cliquez pour revenir)
Standing: Mme Chausson, Ernest Chausson, and Raymond Bonheur.
Seated on the ground: Claude Debussy


In 1893, Claude Debussy wrote to Ernest Chausson,

Music really ought to have been an hermetical science, enshrined in texts so hard and laborious to decipher as to discourage the herd of people who treat it as casually as they do a handkerchief! I'd go further and, instead of spreading music among the populace, I propose the foundation of a 'Society of Musical Esotericism'.

His words project a sense of the place and times, ca. 1871-1914, that we call 'Belle Époque Paris', the focus in Europe for the symbolist movement in poetry, and impressionism in painting and music.

Putting to one side the artist's disdain for an uncomprehending audience (imagined or real), it's difficult now to understand just why the music of this era, which audiences today rarely consider 'difficult', was labeled 'decadent' and worse. A major justification was the often cited violations of the holy trinity of  Western music – melody, harmony and rhythm. One critic wrote about a new work that it '[abolishes] rhythm, melody and tonality from music and thus [leaves] nothing but atmosphere.' But critics' focus on these compositional elements was not completely off the mark. If that critic, instead of writing 'abolishes' had written 'reimagines rhythm, melody and tonality' he would have been on to something. A case in point is the 1897 Piece for cello and piano by Ernest Chausson.

Ernest Chausson (1855–1899)
Piéce, Op. 39
Javier Albarés Alberca, cello, Javier Estebarán Crespo, piano
El Jardin de Belagua, 2010

The piece opens under the time signature 54 (five quarter-notes in every bar). This is uncommon in Western music of the 17th-19th centuries where the numerator (number of beats in a bar) is nearly always divisible by 2 or 3 (24, 34, 68, 44, etc.), but it's not unheard of. The second movement of Tchaikovsky's 6th Symphony is written in 54. The way Tchaikovsky handles this is by splitting the 5 into 2+3 beats in every bar, so the effect is a repeating accent pattern 1-2/ 3-4-5 / 1-2/ 3-4-5 / etc. The overall effect is a slightly off-kilter waltz. In his piece Chausson splits 54 the same way, but there is no suggestion of a waltz. For one thing, Chausson's tempo is much slower, and this leaves room for him to 'play' within and across the bar lines. Often the phrasing of the melodic line subtly splits the bar differently, so one part in the piano might express the 2+3 division while the cello phrases its melodic line to split the bar evenly 2-1/2 + 2-1/2. Things get even more complex about half way through the piece when the time signature switches to 74. The overall effect of contrasting meters creates an asymmetry that suggests a poem in free verse.


By now our Belle Époque critic is tearing his hair out, thinking up new pejoratives while trying to find the beat. Fortunately, audiences today have come to learn that to enjoy the beauty in a work such as the Chausson Piece, we only need to relax and just listen.


–– Program Notes for Charlottesville Chamber Music Festival by Stephen Soderberg (2016)

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular Posts

A Concert and a Painting 1911

Image
On Monday, January 2nd, 1911, there was an historic concert in Munich. The program was devoted entirely to the music of Arnold Schönberg: two string quartets, five lieder, and three short pieces for piano. I doubt anyone in the audience at the time would have considered the concert significant, let alone historic, except for Schönberg and his circle – and one man who had recently arrived in Munich, Wassily Kandinsky. He was so taken with Schoenberg's music that he made this sketch for a painting: The sketch indicates colors for the final work: 'Schw[arz]' = black for the piano; 'gelb' = yellow for a mass or large space on the lower right; and  'w[eiß]'  = white for the two posts and the dress of the pianist, Etta Werndorff (see Schönberg's more figurative portrait of Werndorff below). Etta Werndorff, pianist Portrait by Arnold Schönberg Kandinsky completed the painting only a couple of days later. In both sketch and painting, the shapes
Read more

The Basics: Berio's Duetti

Image
Image courtesy of Naxos Records Luciano Berio (1925–2003) Duetti for two violins It can happen that a violinist friend tells a composer one night that, other than those of Bartók, there are not enough violin duets today. And it can happen that the composer immediately sets himself to writing duets that night until dawn… and then more duets in moments of leisure, in different cities and hotels, between rehearsals, travelling, thinking of somebody, when looking for a present... This is what happened to me and I am grateful to that nocturnal violinist whose name [musicologist Leonardo Pinzauti (1926–2015)] is given to one of these   Duetti . [1] This is how Luciano Berio described the genesis of the 34 Duetti for two violins. With the exception of the first duet – a nod to those Bartók violin duos – each of the pieces is associated with one of his friends, inspired by "personal reasons and situations" and connected by "the fragile thread of daily occas
Read more

Blurring: Fauré's Piano Trio in D minor, Op.120

Image
John Singer Sargent Gabriele Fauré and Mrs Patrick Campbell (Charcoal, 1898) *     *     *     * Gabriele Fauré (1845–1924) Piano Trio in D minor, Op.120 In the early 20 th century Debussy, Stravinsky, and Schoenberg revolutionized the foundation of Western music in the areas of tonality, harmony, and symmetric meter. At the same time, Gabriele Fauré was working with this foundation, not by abandoning the traditional structures, but by “blurring” them – especially in his later works. (Christopher Steele, Tonal and Formal Blurring in Fauré’s Piano Trio Op. 120. ) “Blurring” of tradition is an excellent description for Fauré, but impossible to address in a program note. However, a selective sketch of his life might provide a hint. As a composer, from an early age, Fauré developed independently of the establishment. Rather than the Paris Conservatoire, a gateway for any French musician, he attended the École Niedermeyer in Paris.   His early influences came fr
Read more